Healthy skepticism

Besicovitch once said that “A mathematician’s reputation rests on the number of bad proofs he has given.” Of course, originating from someone educated in the Russian school, the word “bad” in the quote should probably be taken to mean “inelegant”. However, lack of beauty is certainly not the only possible deficiency in the quality of a published result. Cases abound where a proof is bad not in the aesthetics, but in something more fundamental.